Page 1 of 3 123 LastLast
Results 1 to 20 of 50

Thread: Way too early 2018 D2 Football Poll

  1. #1
    Join Date
    Sep 2014
    Posts
    1,673
    Contribute to D2
    Rep Power
    94938

    Default Way too early 2018 D2 Football Poll

    I didn't take the time to go through every teams roster. Just some casual observations and from watching the playoffs last year and lurking on the board. I also did this by how I think teams will fare in the playoffs if the playoffs weren't done by region. Sorry region 1, history has shown us that you typically fall flat in the semifinals with Sheperd being the only exception that comes to mind in the recent pass. Apologies Bloomsburg. 17 years ago doesn't count. Same to you CIAA.

    1. West Florida
    2. Harding
    3. Central Washington
    4. Texas A&M Commerce
    5. Minnesota State
    6. West Alabama
    7. Ferris State
    8. Fort Hays State
    9. Minnesota Duluth
    10. Central Missouri
    11. Indianapolis
    12. Grand Valley
    13. Ashland
    14. IUP
    15. Tuskegee
    16. West Georgia
    17. Pittsburg State
    18. Midwestern State
    19. Sheperd
    20. Assumption
    21. Northwest Missouri State
    22. Winona State
    23. Virginia State
    24. Arkansas Tech
    25. Ouachita Baptist

  2. #2
    Join Date
    Nov 2000
    Location
    Rockwall, TX
    Posts
    9,603
    Rep Power
    31779

    Default Re: Way too early 2018 D2 Football Poll

    Interesting list with us at #4. We beat #1, #2, #3 and #5 in consecutive weeks this season. I have no idea who is losing what this season, but in terms of difficulty and watching all 4 of those games, this past season I'd put them at:

    Central Washington
    Minnesota St
    Harding
    West Florida

    Just my opinion of course, but I honestly thought West Florida was the lowest in terms of difficulty of those teams mentioned. But they seem to be the Cinderella team of this offseason so far.

  3. #3

    Default Re: Way too early 2018 D2 Football Poll

    Quote Originally Posted by LionFan View Post
    Interesting list with us at #4. We beat #1, #2, #3 and #5 in consecutive weeks this season. I have no idea who is losing what this season, but in terms of difficulty and watching all 4 of those games, this past season I'd put them at:

    Central Washington
    Minnesota St
    Harding
    West Florida

    Just my opinion of course, but I honestly thought West Florida was the lowest in terms of difficulty of those teams mentioned. But they seem to be the Cinderella team of this offseason so far.
    Your opinion doesn't count!!

    Fair enough points. My thinking was this.
    West Florida made it that far with a very young team, they got a taste of what it takes and will come back hungry and focused.

    Harding returns 17/22 starters or something crazy like that and is the first GAC team to have any success in the playoffs they can build off of that.

    I don't follow Central Washington all that close but I know they are a solid team full of athletes that returns a good amount of players. I could easily move them up based on someone like you who has seen them play.

    As for you guys you have to replace one of your all time great QB's and honestly one of the best I have seen in D2 for a while. In addition no matter what Northwest Missouri tells you it is VERY hard to repeat.

    Minnesota State had a tough draw and was a team that got better as the year went on. I think they will be on of the top teams next year.

  4. #4
    Join Date
    Nov 2011
    Location
    USA
    Posts
    236
    Rep Power
    3132

    Default Re: Way too early 2018 D2 Football Poll

    Prediction: Alderson-Broaddus will finish the 2018 football season with a winning record. That'll be a big improvement considering they only won 3 games in 2017. Go Battlers!

  5. #5
    Join Date
    Sep 2010
    Location
    Canada/Texas
    Posts
    4,019
    Rep Power
    69419

    Default Re: Way too early 2018 D2 Football Poll

    I think Bowie State is probably more worthy of top 25 consideration above VSU. JMO

  6. #6

    Default Re: Way too early 2018 D2 Football Poll

    Way too early doesn’t matter just put my young Argos in the region anywhere we played every game on the road last year in the playoffs... take away the first quarter in KS we shake off the young nerves it’s a 1 score game.. but the GSC has about 4 teams who could win the region so I can’t wait until August!!!

  7. Default Re: Way too early 2018 D2 Football Poll

    Quote Originally Posted by Wallst View Post
    I didn't take the time to go through every teams roster. Just some casual observations and from watching the playoffs last year and lurking on the board. I also did this by how I think teams will fare in the playoffs if the playoffs weren't done by region. Sorry region 1, history has shown us that you typically fall flat in the semifinals with Sheperd being the only exception that comes to mind in the recent pass. Apologies Bloomsburg. 17 years ago doesn't count. Same to you CIAA.

    1. West Florida
    2. Harding
    3. Central Washington
    4. Texas A&M Commerce
    5. Minnesota State
    6. West Alabama
    7. Ferris State
    8. Fort Hays State
    9. Minnesota Duluth
    10. Central Missouri
    11. Indianapolis
    12. Grand Valley
    13. Ashland
    14. IUP
    15. Tuskegee
    16. West Georgia
    17. Pittsburg State
    18. Midwestern State
    19. Sheperd
    20. Assumption
    21. Northwest Missouri State
    22. Winona State
    23. Virginia State
    24. Arkansas Tech
    25. Ouachita Baptist
    It's comical how you folks on the other side of the country think. This past season CSU Pueblo lost to Minnesota State in the first round at Mankato in overtime and CSU Pueblo returns completely stacked with talent and they aren't even listed in the top 25.

  8. #8

    Default Re: Way too early 2018 D2 Football Poll

    Quote Originally Posted by WalterCampFan View Post
    It's comical how you folks on the other side of the country think. This past season CSU Pueblo lost to Minnesota State in the first round at Mankato in overtime and CSU Pueblo returns completely stacked with talent and they aren't even listed in the top 25.
    "Other side of the country"?

    You do realize WallSt's favorite team resides in a state that borders Colorado? ;)

  9. Default Re: Way too early 2018 D2 Football Poll

    I've got a sleeper for you in Missouri S&T. I believe they are a top 25 team. They return almost everyone from a potent offense. Also heard of rumors of a couple new faces who could be difference makers.

  10. #10
    Join Date
    Dec 2009
    Location
    Pensacola, FL
    Posts
    8,442
    Rep Power
    669449

    Default Re: Way too early 2018 D2 Football Poll

    Quote Originally Posted by LionFan View Post
    Interesting list with us at #4. We beat #1, #2, #3 and #5 in consecutive weeks this season. I have no idea who is losing what this season, but in terms of difficulty and watching all 4 of those games, this past season I'd put them at:

    Central Washington
    Minnesota St
    Harding
    West Florida

    Just my opinion of course, but I honestly thought West Florida was the lowest in terms of difficulty of those teams mentioned. But they seem to be the Cinderella team of this offseason so far.
    I don't think either TAMUC or UWF will finish in the Top 10 but definitely should be listed that way in a pre-season poll.

    We'll see what the Lions can do without Perez and we'll see if the Argos can make it through the GSC with the huge target painted on their backs now.

  11. #11
    Join Date
    Nov 2011
    Location
    USA
    Posts
    236
    Rep Power
    3132

    Default Re: Way too early 2018 D2 Football Poll

    Quote Originally Posted by WalterCampFan View Post
    It's comical how you folks on the other side of the country think. This past season CSU Pueblo lost to Minnesota State in the first round at Mankato in overtime and CSU Pueblo returns completely stacked with talent and they aren't even listed in the top 25.
    The infamous East Coast bias rant. LOL

  12. #12
    Join Date
    Jun 2007
    Location
    portales, nm
    Posts
    4,743
    Rep Power
    392748

    Default Re: Way too early 2018 D2 Football Poll

    Quote Originally Posted by crixus View Post
    The infamous East Coast bias rant. LOL
    But he does have a point, their defense nearly single handedly won the game for them, and they return nearly the whole unit.

  13. Default Re: Way too early 2018 D2 Football Poll

    Quote Originally Posted by WalterCampFan View Post
    It's comical how you folks on the other side of the country think. This past season CSU Pueblo lost to Minnesota State in the first round at Mankato in overtime and CSU Pueblo returns completely stacked with talent and they aren't even listed in the top 25.
    Really does not matter how you are ranked at the beginning of the year. It is how you finish. I am sure the T- Wolves will be in the D2 Playoffs next November. It is almost automatic for CSU-P each year.

  14. #14

    Default Re: Way too early 2018 D2 Football Poll

    That Pueblo team last year was not very good. The RMAC in general was bad.

  15. #15
    Join Date
    May 2007
    Location
    Lionville, Pennsylvania
    Posts
    95,696
    Rep Power
    1000000

    Default Re: Way too early 2018 D2 Football Poll

    Quote Originally Posted by Wallst View Post
    I didn't take the time to go through every teams roster. Just some casual observations and from watching the playoffs last year and lurking on the board. I also did this by how I think teams will fare in the playoffs if the playoffs weren't done by region. Sorry region 1, history has shown us that you typically fall flat in the semifinals with Sheperd being the only exception that comes to mind in the recent pass. Apologies Bloomsburg. 17 years ago doesn't count. Same to you CIAA.

    1. West Florida
    2. Harding
    3. Central Washington
    4. Texas A&M Commerce
    5. Minnesota State
    6. West Alabama
    7. Ferris State
    8. Fort Hays State
    9. Minnesota Duluth
    10. Central Missouri
    11. Indianapolis
    12. Grand Valley
    13. Ashland
    14. IUP
    15. Tuskegee
    16. West Georgia
    17. Pittsburg State
    18. Midwestern State
    19. Sheperd
    20. Assumption
    21. Northwest Missouri State
    22. Winona State
    23. Virginia State
    24. Arkansas Tech
    25. Ouachita Baptist
    IUP 14th?

    Seriously?

  16. Default Re: Way too early 2018 D2 Football Poll

    Quote Originally Posted by IUPNation View Post
    IUP 14th?

    Seriously?
    What’s wrong with #14...?

  17. #17
    Join Date
    May 2007
    Location
    Lionville, Pennsylvania
    Posts
    95,696
    Rep Power
    1000000

    Default Re: Way too early 2018 D2 Football Poll

    Quote Originally Posted by every1ftballfan View Post
    What’s wrong with #14...?
    They were a final four team last year and are returning most of the team.

    They were ranking in the top 3 going into last year's playoffs.

    Obviously this person knows nothing about IUP foosball.

  18. #18
    Join Date
    Jun 2007
    Location
    portales, nm
    Posts
    4,743
    Rep Power
    392748

    Default Re: Way too early 2018 D2 Football Poll

    Quote Originally Posted by IUPNation View Post
    They were a final four team last year and are returning most of the team.

    They were ranking in the top 3 going into last year's playoffs.

    Obviously this person knows nothing about IUP foosball.
    Maybe this person knows that IUP would have been a first round exit if they faced stiffer competition?

  19. #19

    Default Re: Way too early 2018 D2 Football Poll

    Quote Originally Posted by IUPNation View Post
    They were a final four team last year and are returning most of the team.

    They were ranking in the top 3 going into last year's playoffs.

    Obviously this person knows nothing about IUP foosball.
    I'm sure the foosball team is unstoppable as well. Just ask Helen Boucher.

    Now we will move on to your reading comprehension. Long before you got your undies in a kerfuffle I said this above my initial rankings. "I also did this by how I think teams will fare in the playoffs if the playoffs weren't done by region. Sorry region 1, history has shown us that you typically fall flat in the semifinals with Sheperd being the only exception that comes to mind in the recent pass. Apologies Bloomsburg. 17 years ago doesn't count. Same to you CIAA."

    I'm not sure what there is to argue about?

  20. #20

    Default Re: Way too early 2018 D2 Football Poll


Page 1 of 3 123 LastLast

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •